|
Why
my child is failing in school?
Your
child is not doing well in school. Homework does not get done, what is
done is done poorly, or child hates the school. All of these situations
are devastating for a family. Figuring out why child is not doing well
can be a difficult process depending on the number and complexity of underlying
causes.
There are generally five reasons why children do not do well in school;
1. Learning disabilities
2. ADHD
3. Physical or mental problems
4. Child abuse or neglect
5. Lack of proper teaching
Any one of
these reasons, if present by itself is enough to cause failure in school,
but often more than one of these reasons is involved. Most young patients
in my practice have problems in the first three categories, which are
the most common ones, however, over the years I have seen school failures
steaming from the latter two as well. In this article I will address only
the first cause, the LEARNING DISABILITIES.
Imagine a teacher telling children to bring some tools to school because
the students will be building bookshelves. The following day, most children
bring all the necessary tools, some bring only a few, and a handful do
not bring any. The teacher gives the children instructions, and at the
end of the class, most children finish their work on time, some finish
partly, and a few make no progress at all. Interestingly, those who failed
were not necessarily those who forgot to bring a full set of tools. For
example, one student who forgot to bring glue used a hammer and nails
with good results. That student's success with the task depended on his
skillful and versatile use of the tools he had. Those who failed did so
because of lack of some crucial tools and also their inability to use
the tools they did have.
What tools do children need to do well in school?
a) Focusing
You have heard about ADHD. How many times have you said to your child, "Pay attention!" Attention
supervises all new learning. Ability to initiate, maintain and shift
attention is crucial in all activities
but particularly important in school learning. So important, in fact,
that failure in this vital function can be placed in a separate category
called ADHD,
b) Memory
Memory can be divided in three types:
- Immediate Recall that deals with information which stays in our focus
only for a very short period of time while the brain decides whether to
let it perish or forward it for long term memory.
- Active Working Memory (AWM) that can be compared with the RAM (Rapid
Access memory) in your computer. AWM keeps the information long enough
to be used for ongoing tasks. It allows the user to get distracted for
a short time to a different task and get back to the previous work without
losing it. Examples might be a phone call that interrupts your reading
of a mystery novel for a few minutes and when you return your memory still
retains the plot.
- Long Term Memory preserves the information for a longer time periods.
An example might be the name of your childhood friends, the color of your
school team uniform, tune for the national anthem, smell of roses.
c) Language skills
Most of what children learn in school is presented in form of language.
Language problems can affect not only their academic learning but also
social functioning. Language skills are not limited to just vocabulary,
but effect grammar and ability to converse and also to express oneself
in writing.
d) Processing
Information enters the brain through two main pathways: Auditory (listening)
and Visual (seeing). There are also minor pathways: tactile (touch), olfactory
(smell), stereognosis (shapes), etc.
Auditory and Visual processing
The amount of information entering through Auditory (listening) pathways
is limited to individual child's maturity and abilities. How much a chills
can learn depends on the rate (speed at which information arrives at
a
processing "gate"), volume (amount of information given at
one time), and complexity of the information. Once sum of all three factors
reaches the threshold, the resulting clutter creates a bottleneck preventing
new learning.
Visual (seeing)
processing or pathway is usually divided into sequential (when precise
order of data matters: an example will be the sequence of digits in a
phone number vs. what numbers are there or arrangement or exact order
of colors in a rainbow) and simultaneous when the big picture is much
more important than particular details (e.g. how heavy the traffic is
on the freeway vs. details on each individual car.) Visual processing
is limited by the same factors as the auditory processing (rate, volume
and complexity.)
e)
Motor skills
There are gross motor (big muscles of the body movement, coordination,
etc.) and fine motor skills (mostly handwriting skills) and motor (also
known as procedural) memory to be considered.
Gross motor
skills are not as important as fine motor skills in academics; nevertheless,
poor eye-hand coordination or general clumsiness may have substantial
impact on self esteem and social standing.
Fine motor
skills are more important during the early years of schooling. With spread
of computers, handwriting becomes less and less relevant for academic
success.
f)
Higher cognitive function (HCF)
Also called the filing system of the brain. Just as the filing system
for books in a library, the HCF controls storage and retrieval of the
necessary information. It tags new information under different categories
creating multiple connections within the brain. HCF allows to label, prioritize,
inter-connect and group independent pieces of information to bring it
back from memory at will, answer indirect questions, or in order to solve
a new problem. HOC is also important in planning, estimation, preparation
for the tests and other complex tasks requiring advanced skills.
Different tasks in school require the ability to combine the various skills
or tools we have just listed here. We understand that for reading (decoding,
not comprehension) we employ attention, language, and visual processing
skills; for copying from a black board - attention, visual sequential
processing, short term visual memory and fine motor skills; for creative
writing, a more complex task, - attention, planning, memory, language
skills, fine motor skills, but not auditory or visual processing (e.g.
children can still write with their eyes closed)
Deficiency
of one particular tool will only affect tasks requiring this skill but
not other tasks. Therefore, it is not unusual to have a child who can
read above grade level but not able to write well.
How does
knowing these help you? What do you do if your child is failing? Most
parents are not able to separate out and identify their child's abilities
and disabilities.
A qualified
specialists can perform a psycho-educational evaluation which will help
you identify the areas of strength and weaknesses. It can be done either
privately or at the public school (where it is called the IEP evaluation.)
The testers can administer an IQ test to check child's abilities and also
achievement tests to see how well the child performs academically. They
will arrange for speech and language tests if necessary, and collect information
from parents and teachers to get a complete picture. Also, a medical specialist
or a psychologist may need to be involved for diagnosis and treatment
of ADHD or specific psychiatric disorders that cause the school failure.
Once you examine the child's abilities in this fashion, you will get a
better picture of what the primary cause of your child's problem in school.
Appropriate plan to help the child can then be formulated to specifically
address his or her weak areas.
Michael Levin
M.D.
|